Visit Scott (Scoop) Butki's column >>

SCOTT (SCOOP) BUTKIHome Page

A cynical idealist; To Read Me Is to Know Me (Mostly)
Add To Watchlist
Articles Posted: 1176; Links Seeded: 7571
Member Since: 2/2007Last Seen: 11/28/2009

With "Joy," House Offers Up An Episode That Will Thrill Some Fans, While Disappointing Others (Major Spoilers)

advertisement

Reviewing the Oct. 28 episode of House is a bit like analyzing someone's mother in law - some are going to love her, some are going to hate her and many will have mixed emotions.

So it is that I bravely, hesitantly, begin.

Fans of a relationship between grumpy ol' House and hospital administrator Cuddy are probably besides themselves this week watching the final five minutes on a loop. Opponents of a Cuddy-House hookup are cringing, fearing everything from the show becoming cliched to that kiss being the kiss of death that similarly led to the demise of other good shows like Moonlighting which went downhill once the couple began getting it on.

Me? I'm somewhat ambivilent on the topic. I think Cuddy is an interesting character and so I am looking forward to seeing more depth in her character. I am not sure her actions in this episodes made a lot of sense, seemingly going from hating and peeving at House to kissing him, but then some will say love makes one do such weird things.

There were essentially two main stories on this episode, one being Cuddy coming so close to becoming an adoptive mother only to have that baby literally snatched away from her at the last minute. The interactions between the birth mother and the presumed adoptive mother were very well done - the acting, the writing were stellar. I couldn't do it justice recapping it so I won't try.

Less interesting to me was the patient of the week, who had trouble with blackouts. It led to some pointless scenes (except maybe to shock some viewers) involving drugs and drug dealers and reminding us, in case we forgot, of 13's drug use and lingering questions from last week's episode.

Misc. notes:
The acting in this entire episode by Lisa Edelstein, who plays Cuddy, was amazing. A definite Emmy-winning-worth performance

Has anyone else noticed the show seems to be experimenting more with camera angles and perspectives? This was particularly obvious during the show's opening five minutes.

As usual the show's dialogue and writing was amazing.
I mean, how often do you have a put down like this, when House talks to Cuddy: "This is a mistake... You are a control-thinking narcisist, which is fine - good even in some jobs - but you are not equipped to handle a real kid let alone a factory second."

But let me end this review with the exchange that ends this show:
House shows up at her house and she is an emotional wreck and understandably so. "This is really not the greatest time for gloating," she tells him.

House, despite comments like the above, said, "You would have made a great mother."

Cuddy lets him have at it, calling him an SOB and asking why he has to always negate everything?

In one of those rare displays that he feels and thinks about others he says he does not know why he does that. And then smoocharama. He then says good night and she deos not say good night back until he has left as the "Oh, god, tell me I didn't just kiss House" look is on her face.

Related links:

Season opener - reviewed by Vacelts, reviewed by Polite Dissent

Second episode- reviewed by Vacelts, reviewed by Polite Dissent

My interview with Polite Dissent about House

My review of the Sept. 30 Episode of House is here

My review of Birthmarks, and Polite Dissent's review

Polite Dissent's review of "Lucky 13" (I took last week off, lazy slacker that I am)

Want to review tv shows for Newsvine's TV-Guide group? Just email me. My advice to tv recappers is here and Vacelts advice is here.

An ongoing general discussion of tv shows and movies is here

  • 7 Votes
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top

Published to:

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
16
5.0
{"commentId":3779551,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

What did you think of Tuesday's show?

And what do you think of the House-Cuddy kiss? Can you think of other examples of a show jumping the shark post-kiss? Cheers?

Conversely, have there been any series where the show improved once main characters acted on their romantic urges?

{"commentId":3779551,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#1 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 7:47 AM EDT
{"commentId":3781973,"authorDomain":"vacelts"}

I know that kiss was suppose to be the big moment of show this week, but it was an after thought for me.  I spent the whole episode fuming at House.

I know he's Mister Hard to Get Along With, but I think he hit a new low this season, but particularly this episode.  I was so angry with him for ruining Cuddy's happiness. 

Being a mom (or becoming one) is hard enough without some arrogant ass trying to pick you apart.

And then trying to show up at the end to comfort her (or ease his guilt for giving her a hard time) drove me nuts.  If I were Cuddy I'd never let him in my house.

But that shows us that despite her exasperation with House at times, she has feeling for him, which explains the kiss.

A good episode in that he made me scream at the TV, but as a mom hard to watch.

{"commentId":3781973,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"vacelts"}
  • 3 votes
#1.1 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 10:33 AM EDT
{"commentId":3782488,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

I know some who gave up long ago on the show because they grew tired of House always being an ass. It's good that they are starting to show he has some redeeming feelings... sometimes.. but for some it's way too late.

One reason this review was hard to write was I saw the last 30 minutes before I saw the first 30 minutes so when I rewatched I knew what to expect.

The teaser for the next episode - in two weeks (bumped due to election coverage) seems to imply Wilson too has feelings for Cuddy.

{"commentId":3782488,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 2 votes
#1.2 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 10:56 AM EDT
{"commentId":3786524,"authorDomain":"vacelts"}

Oh, I think it's obvious that Wilson has feelings for Cuddy.  Think of all the things he does for her.  And they've gone out together before.

{"commentId":3786524,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"vacelts"}
  • 2 votes
#1.3 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 1:43 PM EDT
{"commentId":3793583,"authorDomain":"sal1967"}

I actually liked the relationship possibility between Cuddy and the "investigator" House hired. Sorta May/ December thing.

I actually liked last weeks better. 13 is Bi?????

Love the show.

{"commentId":3793583,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sal1967"}
  • 2 votes
#1.4 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 8:02 PM EDT
{"commentId":3801441,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

Oh, yeah 13 is bi - they mention that a lot.

Wouldn't it be great - and this may be what they have planned - for the detective to hook up with Cuddy. House would then fire him. could that be how the possible spin off they've talked about happen maybe?

{"commentId":3801441,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 1 vote
#1.5 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 10:31 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":3781763,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

Let's see, last week we had a woman who could not cry. This week we had two who could not show emotions. How much do you want to bet we will soon have a patient unable to stop smiling and, no, not just because of botox either.

{"commentId":3781763,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#2 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 10:22 AM EDT
{"commentId":3782703,"authorDomain":"edomaniac"}

My roommate is an avid watcher of house. For me it's a "sometimes" show. I don't have to watch it that often to understand what is going on. Watching the show this week my roommate and I must have sounded clairvoyant because we kept trading predictions back and forth. "The kid will live," "They're going to kiss." I know that most TV is predictable, but I don't feel like I even need to watch the show even casually anymore. 

{"commentId":3782703,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"edomaniac"}
  • 4 votes
Reply#3 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 11:05 AM EDT
{"commentId":3783898,"authorDomain":"spikegary"}

I think that the kiss was the culmination of the sexual tension that has always existed between House and Cuddy, probably because she wa san emotional wreck, she gave in to it and House knew it was a time he could get away with it.  Ass?  Yes.  Smart?  Yes.

Bones got better with Angela and Hodgins together, though they are secondary actors.  Numb3rs?

{"commentId":3783898,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"spikegary"}
  • 3 votes
Reply#4 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 11:58 AM EDT
{"commentId":3786697,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

I haven't watched enough of both to say if they got better after hookups

{"commentId":3786697,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 2 votes
#4.1 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 1:50 PM EDT
{"commentId":3787124,"authorDomain":"vacelts"}

I agree with the Angela and Hodgins hookup. 

Depends on who you are talking about in Numbers.  Charlie and Amita are great together and I never understood why it took so long.  Larry and the female agent that left were weird but cute together and added an interesting element.  However, I've not been particularly interested in any of Don's relationships.

{"commentId":3787124,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"vacelts"}
  • 2 votes
#4.2 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 2:09 PM EDT
{"commentId":3793637,"authorDomain":"sal1967"}

I have to agree with something said earlier, once they hook up it becomes a soap-opera.

I sometimes wonder if the shelf life of a show should be purposely short. I don't watch Lost, but I understand that has dragged on toooooo looooong.

Let a show end on a high and bring on something fresh and new.

{"commentId":3793637,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sal1967"}
  • 2 votes
#4.3 - Thu Oct 30, 2008 8:06 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":3806896,"authorDomain":"firsty"}

sorry for being late to the show. for some reason when i loaded this article yesterday i wasnt able to see or add any comments.

regarding the tension which led to the kiss. it became clear to me early on that house was somehow threatened by cuddy's choice to adopt. it almost seemed like he felt she was rushing things. "things" being whatever relationship house thought was developing or was at least possible.

house is living in a state of stasis. thats often what happens after an injury like his, and is compounded by his reliance on painkillers. he has been unable to move on with his life. in a sense, he doesnt see time passing by like other people do.

it has been suggested in the past that sometime in the backstory, perhaps when cuddy and house were at the same university at some point, the two had had some kind of romantic relationship. the most important line of the show was in the last scene when cuddy asked house, "why do you always have to negate everything?" and he said, "i dont know," just before they kissed. it's obvious that something has been left unsaid in their relationship for the period of time covered by the series, and house's habit of criticizing cuddy in sexual ways (he criticizes everyone, but exactly how he does it is important) makes it seem more than possible that he's been secretly waiting or hoping for a chance to either rekindle or begin a closer relationship with her.

it's only a theory, but, as house says, it fits. and, like i said, that was my first impression after seeing house's reaction to cuddy's quickly impending adoption, and, believing that, the tension in the episode worked very well right up through the last scene. as far as the patients, the mystery was rather dull, the illness they had (after looking it up on wikipedia) doesnt seem to match their odd and conveniently reliable symptoms, and since the father and daughter were so unhumanly unemotional, the audience wasnt given a chance to empathize with them. but they did provide the thematic influence for showing house that living in that static condition, with the implication that it is associated with a lack of expressing or even feeling any emotion, can result in a sudden loss of time.

think about the cold open - the viewer was given a look at the actual experience of the father, who was losing huge chunks of time without knowing it. in a sense, this provided some insight into the way house has gone through life for the past 4 years. the drug use of the father, who was using cocaine because his sleep patterns were so @!$%#ed up (a good reason, but not a good excuse), can be compared to house's drug use - justifiable but still problematic. and it's important to notice, finally - the way that house dealt with the patients.

anyone watching the show from the first minute could see that the daughter seemed to be, like her father (the first patient), unexpressive and cold. something was clearly wrong with both of them. house rarely does patient histories, but he often tries to analyze the behavior of the patient and his or her available friends and family for clues about the patient. when the daughter began showing similar symptoms, halfway through the episode, house merely added her to the file. but it wasnt until 45 minutes in that he actually pulled himself away from cuddy's own distraction

so cuddy's interest in the unborn baby was treated by house as a distraction. but it was actually house who was so distracted (therefore: interested in, not just being an @!$%# to, cuddy) by the mother and her unborn child, and the time cuddy spent with them, that he took so long to diagnose the father and daughter correctly. normally, house would have taken one look at the daugher, made the connection, and the mystery would have been over. so i dont think it was a mistake that the mystery was boring. it was supposed to be boring - it was supposed to be simple. but house's failure to treat it as such (notice that foreman wasnt present in all the differentials - foreman is perhaps the smartest person on the show, and he usually fills in any blanks in house's diagnoses) demonstrated that he was off his game.

so he wasnt just being an @!$%#. he was trying to regain control of the relationship he thought he had control over, and, through the thematic parallels between house and the father, we see that house grew into the realization that parts of his life were flying by without his noticing, that he has actually lost certain opportunities, and that he was trying to do something about it. of course he relies on insults and attacks at first - thats simply the way he's used to controlling things. it wasnt until those werent working anymore, combined with his realization about the patients, that he discovered what he had to do, or wanted to do, anyway, and it's possible that he didnt even realize his feelings until the situation of the father and daughter jolted him awake.

{"commentId":3806896,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"firsty"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#5 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 2:59 PM EDT
{"commentId":3821200,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

Remind me again why I'm the one writing the recaps and reviews when your comments in response are always more eloquent than mine!

{"commentId":3821200,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 1 vote
#5.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:04 PM EDT
{"commentId":3821330,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}
anyone watching the show from the first minute could see that the daughter seemed to be, like her father (the first patient), unexpressive and cold. something was clearly wrong with both of them. house rarely does patient histories, but he often tries

I write comments as I watch the show the first time (then watch it a second to grab key dialogue. I had written down "Could they make that teen any less sympathetic? Please tell me teens aren't really that negative and gloating over parents misfortunes." Got to the final few scenes and realized what the deal was.

{"commentId":3821330,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
  • 2 votes
#5.2 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:13 PM EDT
{"commentId":3821498,"authorDomain":"firsty"}

it's definitely time to give the house writers the benefit of the doubt - when i find myself confused about something to the point that it might seem unbelievable, i figure it has to be either a symptom or a somewhat clumsy but still intentional plot device.

{"commentId":3821498,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"firsty"}
  • 1 vote
#5.3 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:25 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":4016485,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

I'm computerless still (details here) so if someone else wants to write a review/recap of tonite's show please do so. Otherwise I'll just riff off Polite Dissent's review.

{"commentId":4016485,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
    Reply#6 - Tue Nov 11, 2008 12:00 PM EST
    {"commentId":4154140,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

    I really liked this week's episode of House. I think it's my favorite one so far this season in terms of the writing, the acting, the medicine (Polite Dissent's review of the medicine is here), the unpredicted (by me at least) twists and the character advancement of Foreman. And, yes, I did intentionally make this comment spoiler-free

    {"commentId":4154140,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
      Reply#7 - Fri Nov 21, 2008 11:40 AM EST
      {"commentId":4198131,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

      I’m not going to be online much this week – still no computer - so if someone else wants to review or recap House this week be my guest.

      For internet access I'm going to need to pay for kinkos and that does add up.l

      spoiler warning:

      So what did you think about the latest things going on with Foreman?

      {"commentId":4198131,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
        Reply#8 - Tue Nov 25, 2008 11:47 AM EST
        {"commentId":4694473,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}

        There's a good piece in Newsweek here just seeded it here: Headline is:
        No one on TV can be merely good or evil anymore. That's why we're suffering from Antihero Overload.

        Mentions House and Dexter by name

        {"commentId":4694473,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
          Reply#9 - Tue Jan 6, 2009 10:13 PM EST
          {"commentId":4785722,"authorDomain":"sbutki"}
          {"commentId":4785722,"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463","authorDomain":"sbutki"}
            Reply#10 - Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:24 PM EST
            {"canLink":false,"threadId":"403808","isPrivate":false}
            Leave a Comment:
            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
            {"threadId":"403808","contentId":"2055463"}
            Start TrackingStart Tracking
            Stop TrackingStop Tracking